Need 1966 Coke All Stars checklist

[jefferyepayne]

Originally Posted by cubman1941

Jeff,
You are absolutely correct. I had posted asking for a 1966 All Star Set checklist - the note said "Here you are" and I didn't check any further. I know need to go back and change my caps to 1965.
So now I gather the Alderman is a 1966 Coke All Star and the Randle and Meador are from the 1966 Coke National All Star set?

Thank you very much for helping me through this.

Jim

Yes.

[CowboysGuide]

The sheet image I sent is directly from the 1966 Coke Cap Saver Sheet. The list matches the checklist on this website;
http://www.oldbaseball.com/MegaCheck...~NFL&year=1966

This is the checklist for the 1966 National All Stars;
http://www.oldbaseball.com/MegaCheck...~NFL&year=1966

[cubman1941]

Steve,
Sorry I started a problem. The sheet image you sent did say 1965 on top which is why, I think, the confusion reigns. Your checklist matches a Football Guide checklist I just pulled up on the net so I will go with you. Do you know why the Saver sheet had a 1965 date vice 1966? This is for my own edification. I know Topps baseball (and others) had this problem for years until they standardized the industry.
Thanks.
Jim

[CowboysGuide]

Originally Posted by cubman1941

Steve,
Sorry I started a problem. The sheet image you sent did say 1965 on top which is why, I think, the confusion reigns. Your checklist matches a Football Guide checklist I just pulled up on the net so I will go with you. Do you know why the Saver sheet had a 1965 date vice 1966? This is for my own edification. I know Topps baseball (and others) had this problem for years until they standardized the industry.
Thanks.
Jim

It's says "1965 NFL All Star Team affiliation shown on this sheet" because these are the All Stars from the previous season. The '66 All Stars were not on this sheet because the season had not been played yet. The '65 & '64 sheets have that notation for the previous season also.

[cubman1941]

Well, that makes a lot of sense - something says I should have done some thinking before I started all this. Thanks.

[cubman1941]

Reviving this as I have picked up a few more and am now confused. I have re-read all the posts but still am confused. I presume some checklists are either wrong or I don't understand,sorry.
The NFL All Stars Saver sheet says 1965 and has, for example, C37 listed as Ryan. The two checklists I have say 1965 Coke Caps All-Stars NFL C37 as Sonny Jurgensen. I understand CowboysGuide "It's says "1965 NFL All Star Team affiliation shown on this sheet" because these are the All Stars from the previous season. The '66 All Stars were not on this sheet because the season had not been played yet. The '65 & '64 sheets have that notation for the previous season also." makes sense but then the two checklists I use are wrong, correct? They would also be wrong for all the NFL All Star teams?

Thanks.